Brisket Bible

By on February 28, 2019

BrisketBibleFeature1

While the reward is mouthwatering, let’s be real—briskets are intimidating, not to mention high maintenance. There are tons of cooking opinions when it comes to brisket and you’ll come to find that almost all of them are based on personal preferences. We’re here to be your voice of reason and we promise, once you get the hang of it, you’ll love cooking brisket.

Anatomy:

Anatomy

Brisket comes from the lower breast section of the cow and can weigh anywhere from 8 to 20 pounds. This large boneless chunk of meat contains a considerable amount of tough connective tissue. Thus, why many choose to tenderize that tissue down by cooking it low and slow.

Your brisket’s anatomy consists of two main areas—the flat and the point. Most briskets available for purchase will be the flat. The flat is leaner and tends to be a more desirable cut because it’s easier for cooking, while the point is a fattier piece of meat.  But brisket veterans will often tackle what is known as a full or whole packer—a cut of brisket with both the point and flat intact. Outside of the full packer’s high price tag and extended cook time, the end result is always worth the wait.

 

When purchasing a brisket, you’ll find there are three USDA grades. Select is the lowest grade, you’ll find these at your local grocery store or a restaurant chain. Choice brings more flavor and tenderness and can be found at most supermarkets and butchers. Prime is the highest grade of meat. When comparing the three you will notice an increase of tenderness, juiciness, marbling, and flavor. This is in reference to the meat’s fat content. As you could have guessed, choice has a lower fat content than prime. You can typically find Prime at upscale steakhouses and via request from your butcher.

Select Choice PrimeNEW

USDA

Methods:

Methods

There are tons of ways to cook a brisket. Brisket in a stick smoker, brisket in a drum smoker, brisket in a propane smoker, brisket in an electric smoker, brisket on the pellet grill—the list goes on and on. We might be a little biased to pellet grills so we’ll give you our favorite smoking methods.

Low and Slow

Probably the most common brisket cooking method is the classic low and slow. This method entails setting your smoker between 225-250°F and smoking your brisket for upwards of 18 hours. Generally, you will need to account for about  1 hour to 1 hour and 15 minutes per pound. However, this is entirely dependent upon the size of the meat, tenderness, etc.

Hot and Fast

This method is quickly growing in popularity. It’s an effective option for those who are crunched on time. When participating in the hot and fast method your grill is set between 300-350°F and your meat may only sit on the grill for 5-6 hours. While you may be able to get a great brisket result in half the time, there is a larger window for error and overcooking. Plus, you won’t get that same smoky flavor as a low and low brisket.

Sous Vide

The sous vide method offers tenderness beyond your wildest dreams. However, it comes at a cost in the form of time. Your brisket is often soaked with vegetables for added flavor, sealed via a vacuum sealer, and dropped into a circulator or water bath at a temperature around 155°F. Here’s the kicker, you can end up bathing your brisket from upwards of 36 hours. Many people who prefer this method like to throw it on the smoker for an even more robust taste.

Wood:

Brisket_Pellets

Different woods burn differently and not just any variety hardwood will do for a brisket. If you’re looking for a classic bold flavor we recommend a Mesquite or Oak pellet base. If you’re looking for something on the sweeter side try a Cherry or Apple. And if you’re unsure about which hardwood pellets to commit to, the Competition Blend is a safe route.

Trimming:

Trimming

Trimming is essential. First and foremost be sure to always use a sharp knife. We recommend trimming your brisket while it’s cold. If you let it rise to even room temperature your meat will be difficult to cut through and may cause an injury. If you have a full packer, find the deckle (the fat/muscle attaching the flat to the rib cage) and trim it as best you can. Take as much of the silver skin off as you can. During this process, you need to find a happy medium between too fatty and too lean (which will equate to a dry brisket post smoke.) Plan on leaving about ¼ of an inch of fat on your brisket.

BoningKnife

Seasonings:

Seasoning

Seasoning is all up for interpretation, everyone has their own personal preference. When doing so, don’t forget to give the brisket sides a little love too. Keep in mind that you already have an extremely flavorful piece of meat, and it’s only going to get better with time on your pellet grill.

Salt and Pepper

The most common way to season your brisket is a traditional Texas-style salt and pepper rub. Combine equal parts kosher salt and coarse pepper for a simple, yet tasty way to present your brisket. Many brisket purists choose the salt and pepper seasoning method.

Homemade Dry Rub

If you’re looking for something a little more complex, try a homemade dry rub. Bonus: most of the ingredients can be found in your home kitchen!


  • 2 tbsp. kosher or coarse salt
  • 2 tsp. coarse black pepper
  • 2 tsp. paprika
  • 1 tsp. cayenne pepper
  • 1 tsp. oregano leaves (dried)
  • ½ tsp. ground cumin
  • 1 tsp. garlic powder

Store Bought Brisket Rubs

Don’t want to deal with mixing and measuring? There are more than a handful of companies that offer a store bought, pre-mixed brisket rub. Check out companies like Meat Church, Texas Select, and Reload Rub and Seasonings.

Injections

An injector allows you to add flavor beyond just the brisket’s surface. Liquids including beef broth, butter, alcohol, sodas, and even Worcestershire sauce are used in this method.

Grill Placement:

Grill Placement

Deciding whether to put your brisket on the pellet grill while it’s still cold or room temperature is completely up for debate. Many people believe that smoke adheres better to cold meat and that this, in turn, yields a better smoke ring. Others suggest letting your brisket warm up to room temperature (for about an hour) with the idea that starting with a warm piece of meat generates a more tender end result.

When it actually comes to laying your meat on the grill grates it’s best practice to place your brisket’s point towards the fire/heat source. Some people place the brisket fat side up with the idea that once the fat melts, its juices will re-distribute and add moisture to the brisket. Others place the fat side down in order to protect the meat. We’ve tested and consulted with experts on both methods and frankly, it comes down to personal preferences.

The Stall:

NEWBrisketWait

Dun, dun, dunnnn. The dreaded brisket stall is when your brisket’s internal temperature plateaus or stops rising. The stall usually occurs around 160-170°F and can last up to four hours. This can happen when your meat’s internal temperature is gradually inching closer and closer to the smoker’s temperature.  The smoker’s heat starts to melt the brisket’s fat and the evaporation process begins. As moisture is being evaporated from the brisket, it, in turn, ends up cooling the meat. Some people fight through the stall by waiting it out, while others take it off and wrap it.

Wrapping:

Wrapping

Wrapping is a personal preference. However, it’s widely used because it helps retain moisture, prevents burning/drying, and pushes you through a stall faster. Wrapping is typically done once your brisket starts to stall. Are you team tin foil or team butcher paper? The age ole’ debate continues. We won’t pick sides, but we’ll help you make an informed decision. Heck try ’em all and let us know what works for you.

Naked

If you choose not to wrap your brisket at all, you will find that your brisket will need to cook longer (due to the stall) compared to its cozier counterparts (below.) However, there is something to be said about the added smoky flavor and bark.

Butcher Paper

Compared to a naked brisket, butcher paper will decrease your cook time. The extra layer offers a sheet of protection to your brisket, so it won’t dry out. Many cooks love the fact that butcher paper allows their meat to breathe. If your meat is able to breathe, smoke will be able to reach the meat, giving you an authentic smoked brisket taste. Plus, with breathability comes direct heat penetration. You’ll develop a thick crunchy bark in no time. Here’s one of our personal favorites.

Tin Foil

Using tin foil is also known as the Texas Crutch. You’ll get a mixture of steaming, smoking, and baking when wrapping in tin foil—similar to an oven. While your meat will cook faster and pull you through a stall more quickly, a thick bark is often difficult to achieve. The absence of bark is mainly due to a combination of too much moisture and not enough direct heat. However, you’ll notice your meat is more tender due to lack of breathability.

Moisture

You don’t want to constantly check on your brisket, but finding a method to retain moisture is key. Many stick, electric, and propane smokers require a water pan to do so. However, we’ve found that pellet grills do not require a water pan. Instead of wrapping your brisket, you can try spritzing and spraying. This entails putting a liquid of choice in a spray bottle and doing a light meat spray. Mopping is also a popular method where a pot containing a liquid base and seasoning is mopped onto the meat.

brisketmopnew

Time and Temperature:

Time and Temperature

Preheat/set your grill temperature to 225-250°F. Now, keep in mind that every piece of meat is different, and we firmly stand behind the idea of not giving cook times. That being said the general rule of thumb is accounting for an hour to and hour and 15 minutes per pound. We can’t say it enough—keep the lid closed. There’s a saying in the brisket world, “If you’re looking, you’re not cooking.” Spray, mop, and check on your brisket as little as possible.

Internal Temperature

For the best results, you need to actively monitor your meat’s internal temperature. The internal temperature of your brisket should be around 195-205°F (give or take 10°F) at the time you pull your brisket off the grill. Many of our pellet grills offer two meat probes to provide you with a more accurate reading.

Resistance Test/Probe for Doneness

After the brisket reaches around 195°F many people probe test their brisket. This is also called the resistance test and it requires you to check the resistance of both the point and flat every 30-45 minutes. Do this by pushing your probe in and pulling the probe out to assess the resistance. Is it comparable to butter…caramel…etc.? You know it’s ready when the consistency is similar to soft butter or jello. Be sure to make mental notes for the next time you cook a brisket.

Point vs. Flat Temperature

Since you have a probe in both the point and flat, you may recognize that your flat gets done quicker than the point. If this happens, some chose to just let it ride. While other BBQ-ers pull the brisket out, cut off the flat, and return the point to the grill until you reach the desired temperature. The point can then be used to make brisket burnt ends.

Resting:

NEWBrisketCooler

Give it a rest! You’ve heard this time and time again when cooking meat, please for the love of all that is good in this world, allow your brisket to rest. We suggest letting your meat rest for a minimum of 30-60 minutes before serving. However, you can rest your brisket safely for up to 6 hours if needed. Do this by storing your brisket in a Faux Cambro.

Cambro

Slicing:

slicing

When it’s finally time to slice your masterpiece, locate the flat and point. Slices should be around ¼ of an inch on the flat and ⅜ of an inch on the point. 1. Begin on the flat side and slice against the grain working your way towards point. Around this area, the grain will gradually change. 2. Change the direction in which you cut to go against the grain. Continue by finishing with the point.

BrisketKnife

Test:

Tests

If you’re curious as to how your brisket turned out, you can test the bend. The bend is in reference to how tender your meat will be. There are a couple of ways to test that will ultimately give you the same outcome.

Bend Test

Grab a slice of brisket in the middle with your thumb and index finger, if it bends over both sides of your hand without breaking – your meat is tender. Another popular way is to hang the brisket slice over your index finger if it droops over your forefinger you are golden!

Pull Test

Almost exactly as it sounds; the pull test consists of holding a single slice of brisket on its edge, vertically between your thumb and index finger. If well-cooked, the brisket slice should not fall apart under its own weight but should break apart easily with a slight pull/tug.

Serving:

Brisket_Recipe

Sauce and Side Dishes

You can serve your brisket with sauce if you’d like. Many people shy on the side of just letting the meat and smoker do the heavy lifting. It’s up to you.  We also get a ton of questions in regards to brisket side dishes. You can serve brisket with any typical BBQ side dish. Try red beans & rice, cornbread, coleslaw, mac and cheese, starch/potatoes, etc.

Storing and Leftovers

Store in the refrigerator for up to four to seven days. If you have leftovers try making a brisket sandwich (shown above) or brisket chili. Otherwise, cooked brisket can last 2-3 months in the freezer before it loses moisture and flavor.

A Camp Chef Brisket:

Camp Chef has a variety of products that help make brisket smoking seamless. Pick up the 26-inch Bamboo Cutting Board for trimming, seasoning, and slicing your brisket.  All of our pellet grills have the capacity to smoke a brisket—even the Pursuit! Long cooks may result in excess grease so pick up a pack of pellet grill grease bucket liners for easy cleaning.

A Camp Chef style brisket means more than just using our products—it also provides a sense of community. Be sure to check out all the great pro tips in the comment section below given by real Camp Chef brisket smokers. If you’re on Facebook and have a Camp Chef pellet grill, join this customer-ran pellet grill group called Camp Chef Smoker Smokers.


What’s your favorite brisket tip? Let us know in the comment section below!


35 thoughts on “Brisket Bible”

  1. Smoking has quickly become a family hobby. There is no set right or wrong methods. Even your errors can work to your advantage. My tip would be to get a pair of gloves. At some point you will have to handle hot meat. The dog can have a hotdog that falls off the grill. Not my 12lb brisket.

  2. Patience is a virtue when cooking a Brisket. Remember if you’re looking You aren’t cooking. leave the grill closed and use a probe type thermometer.

  3. Cooking at 225*, my 14-15# briskets are consistently hitting 160-170* around the 4 hour mark and 205* around the 6.5 hour mark after wrapping with foil. I have not yet tried to let it go the distance without doing the Texas Crutch. Working night shift, I need to have the brisket done in time to be at work by 6:30pm. I wrap it in a towel and place it in a cooler to keep until dinner time after 11pm. Still piping hot and delicious after all that time in the cooler.

  4. love this bible it has helped me cook a decent brisket for my wife birthday she loves my brisket but it’s usually some times dry
    now it;s moist and perfectly cook i just need to get my chipotle mango rub (home made) to have more mango flavor
    what brian says about gloves is true i have to sets from my turkey fryer (masterbuilt) but you can find on amazon or walmart

    • I am happy to hear your love the Brisket Bible. We will work hard to maintain and add new and emerging trends.

  5. This was a good read. Glad you pointed out the pro and cons. Being sanitary is the most important. Make sure everything is clean before cooking, from hands to kitchen prep and don’t use that old nasty crusted smoker/bbq grate from the previous hot dog and hamburger jamboree!

  6. I have found ‘resting’ the brisket in a foil pan, covered with foil, and placed in a cooler with towels packed under it and on top of it work wonders with a brisket. I’ve heard to wrap it in butcher paper instead of foil, but definitely in a foil pan, you will get a lot of juice out of it. The juice is wonderful, put it in a jar in the fridge to remove the fat that will rise to the top. Use it to moisten the meat for leftovers, make an au jus, or gravy.

  7. I prefer low and slow after a good rub of spices. 220 deg F. Unfortunately my Camp Chef was right before the 2 meat probe came out. So, I use a MEATER and monitor temp with phone. It gives me a good indication of the approximate time to finish and rest the brisket. I do use the single meat probe put in the point and the MEATER in the flat. So far, the brisket has been perfect. Medium to medium rare, full of good juices, and very tender.

  8. I have a verticial smoker. And a pellet grill. Verticial smoker does much better job.take longer but more smokey taste.

  9. I would have to agree with Earl and the others on vertical smokers. I did my 1st brisket Texas Style and smoke it and wrap it in butcher paper and it came out beautiful markings after 15 hours I wish we could have posted pictures lol. Thanks for the tips Camp Chef

    • You’ll have to take pictures next time! We love to hear 1st-time success stories. Thanks, Daniel.

  10. iam brand new to this didn’t see where i could order the bible or download a copy can you help me out

  11. I do a lot of cooking for our local veterans. I did my first 15 lb. Brisket last year for our picnic on our new Camp Chef pellet grill, it was Awesome. The brisket didn’t last 20 minutes. Normally I use any leftovers for Cowboy Baked Beans at the next cook out. Love Camp Chef.

    • Greg,
      We love to hear you are putting your Camp Chef to good use. We might need to snag that Cow Boy Baked Beans recipe from you:) Sounds so tasty!

  12. Brisket is a very intimidating piece of meat. I have only done 2 of them thus far. Love the brisket Bible. So much info in one place. My first brisket I left it go through the stall on its own. I loved the crust, but I let it go to long and dried it out. We chopped it for hash and everyone loved it. Second brisket I did the foil. Made so much juice I couldn’t belive it. Brisket was so moist and tender. I have not ventured away from competition blend pellets. I have never had a complaint about the smoke so no need to change, we cook everything on woodwind. Pizza (fresh dough even) cookies, bread or anything you would do in a oven.

    • Thank you for sharing your story, Jeremy. It’s not always sunshine and rainbows when it comes to brisket. We appreciate your insight. I am a big Competition Blend user as well because it works well for all types of foods.

  13. Great article! I’ve only tried brisket once before on an old smoker. I think I rushed it because it turned out like shoe leather! Got my Camp Chef last fall and have smoked several different kinds of meat. It does an excellent job with everything! One question though, when using butcher paper, do you need to worry about it catching fire?
    Thanks for outting out great articles,
    Scott Stradley

    • Don’t sweat it! I can’t tell you the amount of times I’ve messed up smoking food – I’m certain it’s a right of passage. 🙂 No, butcher paper is absolutely safe for cooking.

    • Thanks, Caytlin. We plan for this document to be ever-green by always adding to it. Thanks for your help in providing insight and content!

  14. I just used the recipe for brisket that came in the instruction booklet for my SmokePro. I use the Bad Byron’s Butt Rub from Costco and it was so tender I didn’t have to worry about the way I cut it. I mean it was GOOD! Ambient temperature affects the cooking time though. I usually start pork butts in the middle of the night.

  15. Just a quick comment that the butcher paper is mostly for low and slow temps. Not sure at what temp the paper would burn or catch on fire. Something to explore?

    • Correct, Low and Slow preferred. But since you don’t go over 350F in the Hot and Fast method you should be good. I would check on the packaging, but most butcher paper is fine even into 400F of indirect heat. Great point, OMAR.

  16. I have smoked at least 6 briskets over the last 3-4 years and found almost all the methods mentioned here will work. I like the non wrapped when wanting a harder bark, especially when chopping vs slicing.. I have only wrapped with paper once and found that it to be effective the paper must be tight enough so that it will do what it was intended to do. It takes practice to wrap it tight enough and yet it breath to be successful. The last would be that be that there are many YOUTUBE video’s showing how to trim a brisket with many different thoughts as to the best way.
    I thank you for putting this bible together as it can help even though of us that think we know all the tricks.

  17. Omar, ignition temperature of paper is 451F. That’s why you can boil water in a paper cup. I always remember the temp by thinking of the book ‘Fahrenheit 451.’

  18. This is good information. I have done a lot of briskets and prefer to wrap in pink butcher paper, plenty of bark and people are wowed when it’s brought out of the cooler and I tear it open(carefully, there are juices). The only thing I would add is don’t waste your money on prime! I have bought a few at Costco, which are prime, because they are about the same price as choice(when choice is not on sale). However, they usually have too much fat so why pay the extra $ only to trim it off, even from Costco. If buying a whole brisket, there are a couple things I look for- 1st – the flat should be uniform and at least about an inch thick at the end(you can trim it up to that but if you can find one that doesn’t need to be trimmed the better) 2nd – when I pick it up, it should feel flimsy and bend easily. If it’s rigid, it has too much fat. This might be hard to do if your store buys them frozen, most around my place do not. Also, don’t be afraid to freeze them. I buy a few when they’re on sale and slowly thaw(4-5) days before I smoke them.

Leave a Reply

Comment *

Name *