Backyard Fire Pit Fun: 8 S’more Recipes that Will Blow Your Mind

By on September 15, 2016

Smores and Fire Pit
Think it’s starting to get too chilly to cook outside? Well, grab a blanket, a thermos of cider, and think again! With a backyard fire pit and a few crazy s’more recipes, you can keep the fun going even on cool autumn nights. Now when you think of a propane fire pit, you probably also picture a puffy, golden marshmallow on a roasting stick in your hand. S’mores and fire—they go together like a pellet grill and pork. One without the other feels wrong. But if you had any sort of a childhood, you’ve already experienced the classic white mallow, melty chocolate square, and honey graham cracker combo. Tonight, it’s time to change things up.

The Negative S’more

The Negative S'more If you’d rather not venture far from the conventional s’more recipe, then the Negative S’more is the one for you. It’s a simple reversal of your favorite ingredients: marshmallow, chocolate graham, cookies ‘n’ cream chocolate square. Yes, please!  

Mind-Blown Rating: “That’s neat.”


Peanut Butter Slam S’more

  Peanut Butter Slam S'more   Sometimes that chocolate in the middle of your s’more gets a little lonely. Why not add its favorite partner in crime, peanut butter? There is nothing that could go wrong with that combination. Try swapping your chocolate square for a peanut butter cup, and let us know how it changes your life.  

Mind-Blown Rating: “Woah.”


Thin Mint S’more

Thin Mint S'more There are two kinds of people in the world: those who don’t like mint, and those who see mint as the delicious, indulgent experience that it truly is. If you belong in the second camp, we have your new favorite s’more recipe right here. Cracker, mint patty, marshmallow. Repeat.

Mind-Blown Rating: “You’re kidding me…”


Berry Hazelnut S’more

Berry Hazelnut S'more Raise your hand if you’re a Nutella fan. Now use that hand to spread some Nutella on your graham cracker, slice a few strawberries, roast a marshmallow, and squash it all together. It’s like you’ve transported your backyard fire pit to Europe for a night.

Mind-Blown Rating: “You can do that?!”


Salted Caramel S’more

Salted Caramel S'mores Admit it—just the thought of a salted caramel s’more is making your mouth water. You don’t need anything fancy to recreate this masterpiece. Just pick up a jar of caramel topping and some sea salt next time you’re at the store. You can spread it on one cracker and enjoy.

Mind-Blown Rating: “Where have you been all my life?”


Caramel Coconut Crave S’more

Caramel Coconut Craving S'more Speaking of caramel, you can take it a step further with this recipe. Switch out the sea salt for toasted coconut shavings, and you’re on your way to an incredible eating experience. We take no responsibility for any cravings you might feel after tasting it.

Mind-Blown Rating: “What. Is. This. Magic.”


Lemon Meringue S’more

Lemon Meringue S'more We know what you’re thinking—citrus on a s’more? Trust us, it’s incredible. This is a great way to use extra lemon curd you have around the house. Pro tip: use homemade lemon curd if you’re into that.

Mind-Blown Rating: “My life will never be the same.”


Key Lime S’more

Key Lime S'more You put the lime in the coconut and…you’ve got yourself a s’more. Really though, all this recipe takes is a bit of lime curd, some toasted coconut shavings, and a marshmallow. You’ve never tasted anything like this before from your backyard fire pit.

Mind-Blown Rating: *EXPLOSION*